Home /
Navigating IAM Compliance with Passwordless Authentication: A Comprehensive Guide to Standards, Regulations, and Certifications

Navigating IAM Compliance with Passwordless Authentication: A Comprehensive Guide to Standards, Regulations, and Certifications

Passwordless authentication is revolutionizing Identity and Access Management (IAM) by enhancing security, improving user experience, and reducing operational costs.

Abstract

Passwordless authentication is revolutionizing Identity and Access Management (IAM) by enhancing security, improving user experience, and reducing operational costs. Effective passwordless implementations—characterized by key factors such as the use of Public Key Infrastructure (PKI), adherence to open standards like FIDO2/WebAuthn, robust cryptographic protocols, and strong multi-factor authentication (MFA)—fully meet or exceed compliance requirements set by various regulatory bodies.

As organizations adopt passwordless solutions, understanding how these technologies align with compliance standards, regulatory requirements, and certifications becomes crucial. This comprehensive guide examines the implications of passwordless authentication within the frameworks of key security and privacy standards and regulations, including but not limited to NIST, ISO/IEC 27001, HIPAA, FISMA, FedRAMP, PCI DSS, CJIS, SOC 1 and 2, GDPR, CCPA, and others.

The guide expands on additional standards such as the Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX), Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA), International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR), and includes insights from agencies like the Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC), Consumer Financial Protection Bureau (CFPB), Federal Trade Commission (FTC), as well as regulatory perspectives from Canada, the UK, the EU, Australia, Brazil, India, and China.

We provide a detailed analysis of the specific technical functionalities and capabilities that make passwordless solutions compliant with these requirements. Additionally, we include a comprehensive checklist that organizations can use to evaluate passwordless vendors, ensuring their solutions meet rigorous compliance standards. Finally, a definitions section is included to clarify key terms used throughout the document. This guide serves as a valuable resource for organizations implementing passwordless authentication, providing clear insights into compliance modifications, technical requirements, and strategic considerations resulting from the transition.

Table of Contents

  1. Introduction
  2. Understanding Passwordless Authenticationsome text
    • 2.1 Advantages Over Traditional Authentication Methods
    • 2.2 Key Factors of Effective Passwordless Implementations
  3. Regulatory and Standards Landscape
  4. Analysis of Compliance Requirements and Passwordless Authenticationsome text
    • 4.1 NIST Special Publication 800-63B
    • 4.2 ISO/IEC 27001:2013 and ISO/IEC 27002:2022
    • 4.3 Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)
    • 4.4 Federal Information Security Modernization Act (FISMA)
    • 4.5 Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program (FedRAMP)
    • 4.6 Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS)
    • 4.7 Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) Security Policy
    • 4.8 Service Organization Control (SOC) 1 and 2 Reports
    • 4.9 General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)
    • 4.10 California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)
    • 4.11 Other Relevant Standards and Regulationssome text
      • 4.11.1 Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX)
      • 4.11.2 Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA)
      • 4.11.3 International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR)
      • 4.11.4 Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
      • 4.11.5 Global Regulatory Perspectives
  5. Positive Impacts of Passwordless Authentication on Compliance and Controlssome text
    • 5.1 Simplifying Compliance
    • 5.2 Cost Reduction
    • 5.3 Enhanced Security Posture
    • 5.4 Impact on Ancillary Controls and Processes
  6. Technical Capabilities Required for Compliance in Passwordless Solutions
  7. Guidance from Regulatory and Standards Bodies on Passwordless Authenticationsome text
    • 7.1 Official Endorsements and Recommendations
  8. ScrambleID and Compliance Alignmentsome text
    • 8.1 Technical Deep Dive
    • 8.2 Intersection with Compliance Requirements
  9. Vendor Evaluation Checklist for Passwordless Solutions
  10. Implementing Passwordless Authentication: Changes to Controls and Technical Requirementssome text
    • 10.1 Technical Adjustments
    • 10.2 Policy and Procedure Updates
    • 10.3 Audit and Assessment Considerations
  11. Future Evolution of Regulations and Certifications
  12. Conclusion
  13. Definitions
  14. References
  15. Disclaimer

Introduction

In the digital transformation era, organizations face increasing cybersecurity threats while striving to provide seamless user experiences. Identity and Access Management (IAM) is critical in safeguarding information assets, and authentication methods are at the forefront of IAM strategies.

Traditional password-based authentication methods are fraught with vulnerabilities and usability issues. Passwordless authentication emerges as a compelling solution, offering enhanced security and usability. Effective passwordless implementations—characterized by key factors such as robust cryptographic protocols, use of Public Key Infrastructure (PKI), adherence to open standards (e.g., FIDO2/WebAuthn), and strong multi-factor authentication (MFA)—fully meet or exceed compliance requirements set by various regulatory bodies.

This guide provides security and technology professionals with a detailed analysis of passwordless authentication's impact on compliance, including how it meets or exceeds regulatory requirements, affects ancillary controls, and simplifies compliance efforts. We also provide a detailed examination of the technical functionalities and capabilities required for a passwordless solution to be compliant. Additionally, we include a comprehensive checklist that organizations can use to evaluate passwordless vendors, ensuring their solutions meet rigorous compliance standards. To assist readers, a definitions section is provided at the end of the document. This guide serves as a valuable resource for organizations implementing passwordless authentication, providing clear insights into compliance modifications, technical requirements, and strategic considerations resulting from the transition.

Understanding Passwordless Authentication

Passwordless authentication verifies a user's identity without the need for traditional passwords. It employs alternative methods such as:

  • Biometric Authentication: Fingerprints, facial recognition, voice patterns.
  • Possession Factors: Hardware tokens (e.g., security keys), mobile devices (e.g., one-time codes, push notifications).
  • Public Key Cryptography (PKI): Utilizing private keys stored securely on devices for cryptographic authentication.
  • Behavioral Biometrics: Analyzing user behavior patterns (e.g., typing rhythm).

Advantages Over Traditional Authentication Methods

  • Enhanced Security: Reduces risks of credential theft, phishing, and replay attacks.
  • Improved User Experience: Simplifies login processes, reducing friction and user fatigue.
  • Operational Efficiency: Decreases password-related support calls and administrative overhead.
  • Compliance Alignment: Meets or exceeds regulatory requirements for strong authentication, simplifying compliance efforts.

Key Factors of Effective Passwordless Implementations

For a passwordless implementation to be effective and compliant, it should incorporate:

  • Strong Cryptography: Use of PKI and asymmetric cryptography to ensure secure authentication.
  • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Combining at least two of the following factors:some text
    • Something You Have: Secure hardware token or registered device.
    • Something You Are: Biometric verification.
    • Something You Know: PIN or pattern (if necessary).
  • Adherence to Open Standards: Compliance with protocols like FIDO2 and WebAuthn for interoperability and security.
  • Device Binding: Associating authentication credentials with specific devices to prevent unauthorized access.
  • Biometric Compliance: Ensuring biometric data is securely stored and processed, with anti-spoofing measures.
  • Auditability: Comprehensive logging of authentication events for compliance and security monitoring.
  • Risk-Based Authentication: Ability to adjust authentication requirements based on context and risk assessment.

Regulatory and Standards Landscape

Organizations must navigate a complex array of regulations and standards that impact IAM practices. Key frameworks include:

  • National Institute of Standards and Technology (NIST)
  • International Organization for Standardization (ISO)
  • Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)
  • Federal Information Security Modernization Act (FISMA)
  • Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program (FedRAMP)
  • Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS)
  • Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) Security Policy
  • Service Organization Control (SOC) 1 and 2 Reports
  • General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)
  • California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)
  • Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX)
  • Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA)
  • International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR)
  • Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)
  • Global Regulatory Perspectives: Canada, UK, EU, Australia, Brazil, India, China

Each framework contains specific controls and requirements related to authentication, access control, and data protection.

Analysis of Compliance Requirements and Passwordless Authentication

4.1 NIST Special Publication 800-63B

Reference: NIST SP 800-63B: Digital Identity Guidelines – Authentication and Lifecycle Management

Key Requirements:

  • Section 5.1.1 Memorized Secrets: Recognizes the limitations and vulnerabilities associated with passwords.
  • Section 5.2 Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Recommends the use of MFA for higher assurance levels.
  • Section 5.1.3 Authentication Using Biometrics: Provides guidelines for biometric authentication, emphasizing Presentation Attack Detection (PAD) and False Match Rate (FMR) standards.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Exceeds Password Requirements: Eliminates passwords, mitigating associated risks.
  • Meets MFA Recommendations: Effective passwordless solutions incorporate multiple factors, aligning with MFA requirements.
  • Biometric Compliance: Adheres to NIST guidelines for biometric use, ensuring secure and reliable authentication.

Quote:

"Verifiers SHOULD minimize the number of secrets that must be memorized by the user." (NIST SP 800-63B, Section 5.1.1)

4.2 ISO/IEC 27001:2013 and ISO/IEC 27002:2022

Reference:

  • ISO/IEC 27001:2013 – Information Security Management Systems (ISMS) Requirements
  • ISO/IEC 27002:2022 – Code of Practice for Information Security Controls

Key Controls:

  • A.9.2 User Access Management: Formal processes for user registration and de-registration.
  • A.9.3 User Responsibilities: Users should be made aware of their responsibilities, including password management.
  • A.9.4 System and Application Access Control: Controls for secure authentication and access methods.
  • A.9.4.3 Password Management System: Systems should enforce strong password policies.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Enhanced Access Control: Effective passwordless methods provide strong authentication mechanisms, enhancing compliance with A.9.4.
  • Simplifies User Responsibilities: Eliminates password management, reducing the burden outlined in A.9.3.
  • Obsoletes Password Management Systems: Renders A.9.4.3 less applicable, simplifying compliance efforts.

4.3 Health Insurance Portability and Accountability Act (HIPAA)

Reference: HIPAA Security Rule – 45 CFR Part 160 and Subparts A and C of Part 164

Key Safeguards:

  • Technical Safeguards (§164.312):some text
    • Access Control (§164.312(a)(1)): Implement technical policies to allow only authorized access.
    • Audit Controls (§164.312(b)): Implement mechanisms to record and examine system activity.
    • Person or Entity Authentication (§164.312(d)): Verify that a person or entity seeking access is the one claimed.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Strengthens Access Control: Effective passwordless authentication enhances access control mechanisms.
  • Improves Authentication Verification: Provides robust methods for verifying identities, exceeding requirements of §164.312(d).
  • Enhanced Auditability: Facilitates detailed logging of authentication events, aiding in compliance with audit controls.

4.4 Federal Information Security Modernization Act (FISMA)

Reference:

  • FISMA – 44 U.S.C. § 3551 et seq.
  • NIST SP 800-53 Revision 5

Key Controls:

  • Identification and Authentication (IA) Family:some text
    • IA-2 Identification and Authentication (Organizational Users): Requires unique identification and authentication of users.
    • IA-5 Authenticator Management: Mandates secure management of authenticators.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Enhanced Authenticator Management: Effective passwordless methods reduce risks associated with password management under IA-5.
  • Supports High-Impact Systems: Provides stronger authentication suitable for systems at FISMA High Impact level.
  • Reduces Credential Compromise Risk: Aligns with FISMA's objective to protect federal information systems from threats.

Quote:

"Organizations should employ strong authenticators based on the sensitivity of the systems." (NIST SP 800-53 Rev. 5, Control IA-2)

4.5 Federal Risk and Authorization Management Program (FedRAMP)

Reference: FedRAMP Security Controls Baseline

Key Controls:

  • IA-2 Identification and Authentication (Organizational Users): Requires multi-factor authentication for privileged accounts.
  • IA-8 Identification and Authentication (Non-Organizational Users): Extends authentication requirements to external users.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Meets High Baseline Requirements: Effective passwordless authentication satisfies stringent authentication controls required for High Impact levels.
  • Facilitates Cloud Security: Enhances authentication mechanisms for cloud services subject to FedRAMP.

4.6 Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard (PCI DSS)

Reference: PCI DSS v4.0

Key Requirements:

  • Requirement 8: Identify Users and Authenticate Access to System Components:some text
    • 8.3: Secure all individual non-console administrative access and all remote access to the CDE using multi-factor authentication.
    • 8.4: Document and communicate authentication policies and procedures to all users.
    • 8.6: Do not use group, shared, or generic IDs, passwords, or other authentication methods.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Exceeds Credential Protection: Eliminates passwords, surpassing requirements for securing passwords.
  • Satisfies MFA Requirement: Effective passwordless methods inherently use multiple factors, complying with 8.3.
  • Enhances Individual Accountability: By binding authentication to individual users, aligns with 8.6.

4.7 Criminal Justice Information Services (CJIS) Security Policy

Reference: FBI CJIS Security Policy Version 5.9

Key Requirements:

  • 5.6 Identification and Authentication:some text
    • 5.6.2.2 Advanced Authentication: Requires advanced authentication for certain access scenarios.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Meets Advanced Authentication: Effective passwordless solutions using biometrics or hardware tokens comply with advanced authentication requirements.
  • Enhanced Security for Sensitive Data: Provides robust protection for criminal justice information.

4.8 Service Organization Control (SOC) 1 and 2 Reports

Reference: SOC 1 and SOC 2 Reports under SSAE 18

Key Trust Services Criteria (SOC 2):

  • Security
  • Availability
  • Confidentiality

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Strengthens Security Controls: Enhances authentication mechanisms, supporting the Security criterion.
  • Improves Availability: Reduces downtime associated with password issues.
  • Protects Confidentiality: Limits unauthorized access, safeguarding confidential information.

4.9 General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR)

Reference: Regulation (EU) 2016/679

Key Articles:

  • Article 32: Security of Processing: Requires appropriate technical and organizational measures to ensure a level of security appropriate to the risk.
  • Article 25: Data Protection by Design and by Default: Mandates data protection measures from the onset of designing systems.
  • Article 5(1)(f): Integrity and Confidentiality: Personal data shall be processed in a manner that ensures appropriate security.
  • Article 4(12): Definition of Personal Data Breach: Unlawful destruction, loss, alteration, unauthorized disclosure of, or access to personal data.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Enhanced Security Measures: Effective passwordless authentication is a strong technical measure under Article 32.
  • Data Minimization: Reduces stored personal data (e.g., passwords), aligning with Article 25.
  • Improved Data Integrity and Confidentiality: Strengthens protection against unauthorized access as per Article 5(1)(f).
  • Reduced Risk of Personal Data Breach: Mitigates risks outlined in Article 4(12).

Quote:

"Taking into account the state of the art... the controller and the processor shall implement appropriate technical and organizational measures to ensure a level of security appropriate to the risk..." (GDPR, Article 32)

Specific Controls Relevant to Passwordless:

  • Article 32(1)(b): The ability to ensure the ongoing confidentiality, integrity, availability, and resilience of processing systems and services.
  • Article 32(1)(d): A process for regularly testing, assessing, and evaluating the effectiveness of technical and organizational measures.

Passwordless Impact:

  • Confidentiality and Integrity: Passwordless authentication enhances the confidentiality and integrity of personal data processing.
  • Regular Testing and Assessment: Passwordless solutions often include mechanisms for monitoring and assessing authentication processes.

4.10 California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA)

Reference: California Civil Code §§ 1798.100–1798.199

Key Provisions:

  • Data Security Requirements: Businesses must implement reasonable security procedures and practices to protect personal information.
  • Definition of Personal Information: Includes usernames and account credentials (which passwords are a part of).

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Reasonable Security Measures: Effective passwordless authentication enhances security procedures, helping to meet CCPA requirements.
  • Reduction of Personal Information Risk: Eliminating passwords reduces the risk associated with personal information breaches.

4.11 Other Relevant Standards and Regulations

4.11.1 Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX)

Reference: Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002

Key Sections:

  • Section 302: Corporate Responsibility for Financial Reports.
  • Section 404: Management Assessment of Internal Controls.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Strengthens Internal Controls: Effective passwordless authentication enhances access controls over financial systems.
  • Improves Data Integrity: Secures access to financial data, reducing risk of unauthorized modifications.

4.11.2 Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA)

Reference: GLBA – 15 U.S.C. §§ 6801-6809

Key Requirements:

  • Safeguards Rule: Requires financial institutions to develop, implement, and maintain a comprehensive information security program.some text
    • 16 CFR Part 314: Standards for Safeguarding Customer Information.
  • Privacy Rule: Governs the collection and disclosure of customers' personal financial information.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Enhanced Customer Data Protection: Strong authentication methods protect customer information.
  • Compliance with Safeguards Rule: Passwordless solutions help implement effective security controls as required under 16 CFR Part 314.4(c).

4.11.3 International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR)

Reference: ITAR – 22 C.F.R. Parts 120-130

Key Requirements:

  • Access Control: Restricts access to defense-related articles and data to authorized persons.
  • Data Security: Requires adequate security measures to prevent unauthorized access.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Robust Access Controls: Effective passwordless authentication ensures only authorized personnel access sensitive ITAR-controlled data.
  • Compliance with Export Controls: Enhances ability to comply with strict access restrictions.

4.11.4 Securities and Exchange Commission (SEC)

Reference: SEC Rules and Regulations

Key Areas:

  • Cybersecurity Disclosures: Requires disclosure of material cybersecurity risks and incidents.
  • Regulation Systems Compliance and Integrity (Reg SCI): Requires policies for system integrity and security.

Passwordless Alignment:

  • Enhances Security Controls: Strengthens authentication measures, reducing cybersecurity risks.
  • Supports Compliance with Reg SCI: Improves system integrity and security through robust authentication.

4.11.5 Global Regulatory Perspectives

The following table summarizes the key regulations from various countries and how passwordless authentication meets or exceeds their requirements:

Country

Regulation

Key Requirements

Passwordless Meeting/Exceeding Requirements

Canada

Personal Information Protection and Electronic Documents Act (PIPEDA)

Principle 4.7 – Safeguards: Personal information shall be protected by security safeguards appropriate to the sensitivity of the information.

Enhanced Security Safeguards: Passwordless authentication employs strong cryptographic methods (e.g., PKI, encryption algorithms) and multi-factor authentication, providing robust protection for personal information. By eliminating passwords, it removes a common attack vector, thereby exceeding the requirements for safeguarding sensitive data under Principle 4.7.

United Kingdom

UK GDPR and Data Protection Act 2018

Mirrors the EU GDPR's requirements, emphasizing data protection and security.

Alignment with Data Security Requirements: Passwordless authentication enhances the security of personal data processing by implementing advanced authentication methods. By reducing reliance on passwords and employing strong cryptographic techniques, it meets and exceeds data security requirements, particularly those related to integrity and confidentiality of personal data under Articles 5 and 32 of the GDPR.

European Union

eIDAS Regulation (EU Regulation No 910/2014)

Establishes standards for electronic identification and trust services.

Supports Secure Electronic Transactions: Passwordless authentication aligns with eIDAS by providing secure methods for electronic identification using technologies like PKI and cryptographic signatures. By adhering to standards like FIDO2/WebAuthn, passwordless solutions facilitate high-assurance electronic transactions and trust services, exceeding eIDAS requirements for authentication assurance levels.

Australia

Privacy Act 1988

Australian Privacy Principles (APPs)

APP 11 – Security of Personal Information: Entities must take reasonable steps to protect personal information from misuse, interference, and loss.

Enhanced Data Protection: Passwordless authentication utilizes strong security measures such as hardware-backed key storage and biometric verification. These measures provide higher levels of protection against unauthorized access, misuse, and data breaches, exceeding the reasonable steps required under APP 11. Additionally, eliminating passwords reduces the risk associated with credential theft and phishing attacks.

Brazil

General Data Protection Law (LGPD) – Law No. 13,709/2018

Article 6, VII – Security: Use of technical and administrative measures to protect personal data from unauthorized access and accidental or unlawful situations of destruction, loss, alteration.

Supports Compliance with Security Requirements: Passwordless authentication implements advanced technical measures, such as multi-factor authentication and cryptographic protocols, to safeguard personal data. By eliminating passwords, it mitigates risks associated with unauthorized access and data breaches, thereby exceeding the security requirements stipulated in Article 6, VII of the LGPD.

India

Information Technology Act, 2000

Personal Data Protection Bill (pending as of 2023)

Section 43A: Requires reasonable security practices to protect sensitive personal data.

Introduces obligations for data protection and privacy.

Enhances Security Controls: Passwordless authentication offers robust security practices by using cryptographic authentication methods and multi-factor authentication. These practices exceed the "reasonable security practices" requirement under Section 43A. By providing strong protection for sensitive personal data, passwordless solutions align with the anticipated obligations of the forthcoming Personal Data Protection Bill.

China

Cybersecurity Law of the People's Republic of China

Article 21: Network operators must adopt technical measures to prevent illegal or unauthorized access, alteration, or disclosure of data.

Strengthens Authentication: Passwordless authentication employs advanced technical measures, such as cryptographic keys and biometric verification, to prevent unauthorized access and data breaches. By eliminating the vulnerabilities associated with passwords, it exceeds the requirements of Article 21, ensuring higher levels of data security and compliance with China's cybersecurity regulations.

Positive Impacts of Passwordless Authentication on Compliance and Controls

5.1 Simplifying Compliance

  • Elimination of Password Policies: Removes the need for complex password policies, such as password rotation, complexity requirements, and account lockout procedures.
  • Reduction of Training Requirements: Users no longer need training on password creation, rotation, and management, simplifying security awareness programs.
  • Streamlined Audits: Simplifies evidence gathering by reducing the number of controls and policies auditors need to review, making audits more efficient.

5.2 Cost Reduction

  • Lower Support Costs: Fewer password resets and account lockouts reduce helpdesk expenses significantly.
  • Reduced Administrative Overhead: Less time spent on enforcing password policies, managing password-related incidents, and maintaining password databases.
  • Efficiency Gains: Faster authentication processes improve user productivity and satisfaction, leading to operational efficiencies.

5.3 Enhanced Security Posture

  • Mitigation of Credential-Based Attacks: Eliminates vulnerabilities to phishing, brute-force attacks, credential stuffing, and password reuse attacks.
  • Improved Incident Response: Limits unauthorized access, making it easier to detect and respond to security incidents.
  • Data Protection: Strengthens protection of sensitive data by ensuring that authentication methods are resistant to common attack vectors.

5.4 Impact on Ancillary Controls and Processes

  • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Inherent in effective passwordless solutions, satisfying regulatory requirements and enhancing security.
  • User Training and Awareness: Simplifies training programs by removing complex password policies, allowing focus on other critical security topics.
  • Access Control and Monitoring: Provides detailed audit logs and enhances access control mechanisms, aiding compliance with monitoring and reporting requirements.

Technical Capabilities Required for Compliance in Passwordless Solutions

To ensure compliance and effectiveness, passwordless solutions should be evaluated against the following detailed checklist. Organizations can use this questionnaire to understand the requirements and assess passwordless vendors.

  1. Standards Compliancesome text
    • FIDO2/WebAuthn Supportsome text
      • Question: Does the solution fully support FIDO2 and WebAuthn protocols for passwordless authentication?
      • Requirement: Adherence to these open standards ensures interoperability, security, and compliance with regulatory guidelines that favor standardized approaches.
    • Certificationsome text
      • Question: Is the vendor certified by relevant standards bodies (e.g., FIDO Certified, ISO 27001)?
      • Requirement: Certifications provide third-party validation of the solution's security and compliance capabilities.
  2. Cryptographic Securitysome text
    • Public Key Infrastructure (PKI) Integrationsome text
      • Question: Does the solution utilize PKI with asymmetric cryptography for secure authentication?
      • Requirement: Use of PKI ensures that private keys remain securely on the user's device and only public keys are shared, enhancing security.
    • Secure Key Storagesome text
      • Question: How does the solution store cryptographic keys? Are keys stored in secure elements or hardware security modules (HSMs)?
      • Requirement: Secure key storage prevents extraction or misuse of private keys, a critical aspect of compliance and security.
  3. True Passwordless Operationsome text
    • Absence of Hidden Passwordssome text
      • Question: Does the solution eliminate passwords entirely, or does it obscure passwords behind the scenes?
      • Requirement: True passwordless solutions should not store or use passwords in any form, including hidden or system-generated passwords.
    • Avoidance of Static PINssome text
      • Question: Does the solution rely on static PINs or codes that functionally replace passwords?
      • Requirement: Static PINs can be as vulnerable as passwords; effective solutions should use dynamic or multi-factor methods instead.
  4. Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA)some text
    • Inherent MFAsome text
      • Question: Does the solution inherently provide MFA by combining multiple authentication factors?
      • Requirement: Combining at least two factors (e.g., possession and inherence) enhances security and meets regulatory requirements.
    • Adaptive Authenticationsome text
      • Question: Can the solution adjust authentication requirements based on contextual risk assessments?
      • Requirement: Adaptive authentication enhances security by responding to potential threats in real-time.
  5. Biometric Securitysome text
    • Biometric Data Handlingsome text
      • Question: How does the solution handle biometric data? Is biometric information stored and processed securely on the device?
      • Requirement: Biometric data should never leave the device and must be protected against unauthorized access.
    • Anti-Spoofing Measuressome text
      • Question: Does the solution implement anti-spoofing technologies like Presentation Attack Detection (PAD)?
      • Requirement: Anti-spoofing ensures that biometric authentication cannot be bypassed using fake biometrics.
  6. Device Binding and Managementsome text
    • Unique Device Registrationsome text
      • Question: Can the solution bind authentication credentials uniquely to specific devices?
      • Requirement: Device binding prevents credentials from being used on unauthorized devices.
    • Device Management Capabilitiessome text
      • Question: Does the solution provide mechanisms to manage, revoke, or replace devices?
      • Requirement: Essential for maintaining security when devices are lost, stolen, or compromised.
  7. Audit and Compliance Reportingsome text
    • Comprehensive Loggingsome text
      • Question: Does the solution record detailed authentication events, including successful and failed attempts?
      • Requirement: Detailed logs are necessary for compliance audits and incident investigations.
    • Compliance Reporting Toolssome text
      • Question: Can the solution generate reports that demonstrate compliance with specific regulations?
      • Requirement: Facilitates the audit process and ensures transparency.
  8. Integration and Compatibilitysome text
    • IAM Systems Integrationsome text
      • Question: Does the solution integrate seamlessly with existing IAM systems, directories, and protocols?
      • Requirement: Ensures that the passwordless solution can be adopted without significant overhauls to existing infrastructure.
    • API and SDK Availabilitysome text
      • Question: Are APIs and SDKs available for custom integrations and extending functionality?
      • Requirement: Supports flexibility and customization to meet specific organizational needs.
  9. User Experiencesome text
    • Ease of Usesome text
      • Question: Is the authentication process intuitive and straightforward for end-users?
      • Requirement: High usability promotes adoption and reduces the likelihood of user errors.
    • Device and Platform Supportsome text
      • Question: Does the solution support a wide range of devices and operating systems?
      • Requirement: Broad support ensures accessibility for all users.
  10. Security Certifications and Assessmentssome text
    • Third-Party Assessmentssome text
      • Question: Has the solution undergone independent security assessments or penetration testing?
      • Requirement: Validates the security posture of the solution.
    • Compliance with Regulationssome text
      • Question: Does the vendor comply with relevant security regulations and standards?
      • Requirement: Ensures that the solution aligns with legal and regulatory obligations.
  11. Risk-Based Authenticationsome text
    • Contextual Analysissome text
      • Question: Does the solution analyze contextual information (e.g., location, device attributes, user behavior) to assess risk?
      • Requirement: Enhances security by adapting authentication requirements based on risk levels.
    • Dynamic Security Measuressome text
      • Question: Can the solution implement additional security measures when anomalies are detected?
      • Requirement: Provides an extra layer of protection during suspicious activities.
  12. Data Protection and Privacysome text
    • Personal Data Handlingsome text
      • Question: How does the solution handle personal data, including biometric information?
      • Requirement: Must comply with data protection laws like GDPR, ensuring data minimization and user consent.
    • Privacy by Designsome text
      • Question: Is the solution designed with privacy principles integrated from the outset?
      • Requirement: Supports compliance with regulations that mandate privacy by design and by default.
  13. Support and Maintenancesome text
    • Vendor Support Servicessome text
      • Question: What level of support does the vendor provide (e.g., 24/7 support, dedicated account managers)?
      • Requirement: Reliable support is crucial for addressing issues promptly.
    • Update and Patch Managementsome text
      • Question: How does the vendor handle updates, patches, and vulnerability disclosures?
      • Requirement: Timely updates are essential for maintaining security.
  14. Scalability and Performancesome text
    • Scalabilitysome text
      • Question: Can the solution scale to accommodate organizational growth and increased user load?
      • Requirement: Ensures long-term viability of the solution.
    • Performance Metricssome text
      • Question: What are the authentication transaction times and failure rates?
      • Requirement: High performance contributes to user satisfaction and operational efficiency.
  15. Future-Proofingsome text
    • Innovation and Developmentsome text
      • Question: Is the vendor actively investing in research and development to address emerging threats?
      • Requirement: Ensures that the solution remains effective against evolving security challenges.
    • Regulatory Adaptabilitysome text
      • Question: Can the solution adapt to future regulatory changes and requirements?
      • Requirement: Important for sustained compliance.
  16. Total Cost of Ownership (TCO)some text
    • Cost Transparencysome text
      • Question: Are all costs, including implementation, licensing, and maintenance, clearly outlined?
      • Requirement: Prevents unexpected expenses and aids in budgeting.
    • Return on Investment (ROI)some text
      • Question: Does the solution offer measurable benefits that justify the investment?
      • Requirement: Ensures that the solution provides value to the organization.

Guidance from Regulatory and Standards Bodies on Passwordless Authentication

7.1 Official Endorsements and Recommendations

NIST SP 800-63B:

  • Recommendation: NIST encourages reducing reliance on passwords and supports the use of authentication methods that are resistant to phishing, man-in-the-middle, and other attacks.
  • Interpretation for Passwordless Technologies: Passwordless authentication aligns with NIST's guidance by eliminating passwords and using cryptographic methods that are resistant to common attacks. Implementing passwordless solutions that comply with NIST standards enhances security and meets federal guidelines.

FIDO Alliance and NIST Collaboration:

  • Recommendation: NIST endorses FIDO standards for strong authentication, recognizing their role in advancing secure authentication practices.
  • Interpretation: Adoption of FIDO2/WebAuthn-compliant passwordless solutions ensures adherence to recognized standards, facilitating compliance and interoperability.

PCI Security Standards Council (PCI SSC):

  • Recommendation: PCI SSC supports the use of secure authentication technologies, including passwordless solutions that meet multi-factor authentication requirements.
  • Interpretation: Implementing passwordless authentication that satisfies MFA requirements can help organizations comply with PCI DSS mandates, particularly in securing access to cardholder data environments.

European Union Agency for Cybersecurity (ENISA):

  • Recommendation: ENISA advocates for strong authentication mechanisms, such as biometrics and cryptographic tokens, to enhance cybersecurity.
  • Interpretation: Passwordless solutions employing these technologies align with ENISA's recommendations, strengthening defenses against unauthorized access and supporting compliance with EU cybersecurity directives.

Australian Cyber Security Centre (ACSC):

  • Recommendation: ACSC recognizes passwordless authentication as an effective method for implementing MFA and improving security.
  • Interpretation: Organizations in Australia adopting passwordless solutions can meet ACSC's guidelines for secure authentication practices, enhancing their overall security posture.

UK National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC):

  • Recommendation: NCSC supports the adoption of passwordless authentication to reduce reliance on passwords and improve security.
  • Interpretation: Implementing passwordless technologies aligns with NCSC's guidance, helping organizations in the UK strengthen authentication mechanisms and reduce vulnerabilities associated with passwords.

ScrambleID and Compliance Alignment

8.1 Technical Deep Dive

ScrambleID is a passwordless authentication solution that leverages advanced technologies to provide secure, user-friendly authentication.

Key Features:

  • FIDO2/WebAuthn Compliance: Adheres to open standards, ensuring interoperability and alignment with regulatory recommendations.
  • Strong Cryptography: Utilizes PKI and secure key storage, protecting cryptographic keys within secure elements or hardware security modules (HSMs).
  • Multi-Factor Authentication (MFA): Combines possession (device) and inherence (biometric) factors, inherently providing MFA.
  • Biometric Integration: Supports device-native biometrics with anti-spoofing technologies like Presentation Attack Detection (PAD).
  • Device Binding: Implements unique device registration and management, binding credentials to specific devices.
  • Comprehensive Audit Logging: Provides detailed logs of authentication events, facilitating compliance reporting and audit readiness.
  • Risk-Based Authentication: Employs adaptive security measures based on contextual risk assessments, enhancing protection.
  • Integration Capabilities: Offers APIs and SDKs for seamless integration with existing IAM systems and applications.

8.2 Intersection with Compliance Requirements

Alignment with NIST, ISO, HIPAA, PCI DSS, GDPR, and Others:

  • Meets or Exceeds Requirements: ScrambleID's technical capabilities align with and often exceed compliance mandates across various regulations.
  • Enhances Security Controls: Strengthens authentication mechanisms by eliminating passwords and using advanced cryptographic methods.
  • Simplifies Compliance Efforts: Addresses specific controls related to authentication, access control, and data protection, reducing the complexity of compliance management.
  • Facilitates Audit and Reporting: Provides comprehensive logging and reporting tools that support compliance audits and demonstrate adherence to regulatory requirements.

Vendor Evaluation Checklist for Passwordless Solutions

Refer to the "Technical Capabilities Required for Compliance in Passwordless Solutions" section for a detailed questionnaire to evaluate passwordless vendors.

Implementing Passwordless Authentication: Changes to Controls and Technical Requirements

10.1 Technical Adjustments

  • Eliminate Password Policies: Remove password complexity, expiration, and reuse policies from security configurations.
  • Update Authentication Systems: Deploy compliant passwordless solutions that integrate with existing IAM infrastructure.
  • Enhance Monitoring Tools: Update security information and event management (SIEM) systems to recognize and log passwordless authentication events accurately.
  • Device Management: Implement robust device management solutions to manage, monitor, and secure devices used for authentication.

10.2 Policy and Procedure Updates

  • Revise Security Policies: Update organizational policies to reflect new authentication methods, including the elimination of passwords and the adoption of passwordless authentication practices.
  • Update User Training: Develop training materials to educate users on passwordless authentication processes, device security, and the importance of safeguarding authentication devices.
  • Adjust Incident Response Plans: Modify incident response procedures to address scenarios unique to passwordless authentication, such as lost or stolen devices, and outline steps for revocation and re-enrollment.

10.3 Audit and Assessment Considerations

  • Evidence Collection: Prepare documentation that demonstrates compliance with new authentication methods, including technical specifications, policy documents, and audit logs.
  • Engage Auditors Early: Communicate changes to auditors proactively to ensure alignment on assessment approaches and understanding of the passwordless authentication system.
  • Continuous Compliance Monitoring: Implement monitoring tools to oversee authentication activities, detect anomalies, and ensure ongoing compliance with regulatory requirements.

Future Evolution of Regulations and Certifications

As passwordless authentication becomes more prevalent, the following evolutions are anticipated:

  • Regulatory Updates: Regulatory bodies may update standards to explicitly encourage or mandate passwordless authentication methods, recognizing their security benefits.
  • Revised Controls: Traditional password management controls may be deprecated or revised, reducing the emphasis on password-related requirements.
  • Biometric Regulations: New guidelines and regulations may emerge focusing on the protection of biometric data, requiring organizations to implement robust privacy and security measures.
  • Global Harmonization: International cooperation may lead to more consistent global standards for authentication, simplifying compliance for multinational organizations.
  • Certification Programs: New certifications may be developed specifically for passwordless authentication solutions, providing organizations with benchmarks for compliance and security assurance.
  • Increased Focus on User Privacy: Regulations may place greater emphasis on privacy considerations related to authentication methods, particularly concerning the handling of personal and biometric data.

Organizations adopting passwordless authentication will be well-positioned to adapt to these evolving regulatory landscapes, benefiting from early compliance and enhanced security postures.

Conclusion

Effective passwordless implementations, characterized by robust technical capabilities such as PKI, strong MFA, adherence to open standards, and secure biometric handling, fully meet or exceed compliance requirements across various regulatory frameworks. By adopting passwordless authentication, organizations can:

  • Simplify Compliance: Reduce control complexity, eliminate outdated password policies, and streamline audits.
  • Reduce Costs: Lower support and administrative expenses associated with password management.
  • Enhance Security: Mitigate risks associated with traditional passwords, including phishing and credential theft.
  • Improve Ancillary Controls: Strengthen MFA, simplify user training, and enhance access control and monitoring capabilities.

Implementing solutions with the necessary technical functionalities ensures compliance alignment and positions organizations to adapt to future regulatory evolutions. Organizations are encouraged to utilize the provided checklist to evaluate passwordless vendors thoroughly, ensuring that the chosen solution meets the high standards required for effective and compliant passwordless authentication.

Definitions

  • Authentication: The process of verifying the identity of a user or device.
  • Biometric Authentication: Authentication using biological characteristics (e.g., fingerprints, facial recognition).
  • Compliance: Adherence to laws, regulations, guidelines, and specifications relevant to business processes.
  • Credential: An object or data structure that authoritatively binds an identity (and optionally, additional attributes) to a token possessed and controlled by a subscriber.
  • Cryptography: The practice and study of techniques for secure communication in the presence of adversarial behavior.
  • Device Binding: Associating authentication credentials with a specific device.
  • FIDO2: An open authentication standard that enables passwordless authentication.
  • IAM (Identity and Access Management): A framework of policies and technologies for ensuring that the right individuals access the right resources.
  • MFA (Multi-Factor Authentication): An authentication method that requires two or more independent credentials.
  • PKI (Public Key Infrastructure): A system for the creation, storage, and distribution of digital certificates which are used to verify that a particular public key belongs to a certain entity.
  • Passwordless Authentication: Authentication methods that do not require the user to provide a password.
  • Risk-Based Authentication: An authentication method that adjusts the required level of authentication based on the assessed risk of the login attempt.
  • WebAuthn: A web standard published by the World Wide Web Consortium (W3C) for passwordless authentication.

References

  1. NIST Special Publication 800-63B: Digital Identity Guidelines – Authentication and Lifecycle Management
  2. ISO/IEC 27001:2013: Information technology — Security techniques — Information security management systems — Requirements
  3. ISO/IEC 27002:2022: Information security, cybersecurity and privacy protection — Information security controls
  4. HIPAA Security Rule: Summary of the HIPAA Security Rule
  5. NIST SP 800-53 Revision 5: Security and Privacy Controls for Information Systems and Organizations
  6. FedRAMP Security Controls: FedRAMP Security Controls Baseline
  7. PCI DSS v4.0: Payment Card Industry Data Security Standard
  8. FBI CJIS Security Policy: CJIS Security Policy Version 5.9
  9. AICPA SOC Reports: SOC 2® - SOC for Service Organizations: Trust Services Criteria
  10. General Data Protection Regulation (GDPR): Regulation (EU) 2016/679
  11. California Consumer Privacy Act (CCPA): Text of the CCPA
  12. Sarbanes-Oxley Act (SOX): Summary of the Sarbanes-Oxley Act of 2002
  13. Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act (GLBA): FTC Gramm-Leach-Bliley Act
  14. International Traffic in Arms Regulations (ITAR): U.S. Department of State - Directorate of Defense Trade Controls
  15. FIDO Alliance: Passwordless Authentication
  16. ENISA: Guidelines on Secure Authentication
  17. Australian Cyber Security Centre (ACSC): Multi-Factor Authentication
  18. UK National Cyber Security Centre (NCSC): Authentication methods
  19. FTC Guidance on GLBA Safeguards Rule: FTC Safeguards Rule
  20. ScrambleID Technical Documentation: ScrambleID Documentation (Note: Hypothetical reference for illustration purposes)

Disclaimer

This guide is intended for informational purposes only and does not constitute legal advice. While efforts have been made to ensure the accuracy of the information provided, organizations should consult with legal and compliance professionals to understand the specific implications of implementing passwordless authentication solutions within their regulatory frameworks. The authors and publishers of this guide accept no liability for any errors or omissions or for any losses or damages arising from the use of this information.

‍

Table of content

Text Link
Text Link